Posted by: Maryam on: Thursday, April 17, 2008
Some days back I was requested by Baikong, to read this book ‘The Alchemist’ and post my opinion about it. Luckily this book was available in the library nearby, wasted no time in bringing it home and started reading it.
To be quite honest with you all, I did not like the story atall. It would rather serve as an ideal
bed-time story for me. There came many times while i was reading it, when i wanted to stop reading the fairy tale. But, I had to go on, for Baikong. I do not believe in Fairy-tales atall, they in a way annoy me. This was on of them, who dint fail to annoy me too. Some of the situations were too superficial to believe in, And what i dont/cannot believe, I dont like it. Thats it … !!!
The bottom line of the story, i.e to follow our dreams and realise the reason behind our existance, is the only thing that i could relate myself or any normal human life with. Believing in omens, understanding them and moving ahead in life according to them, Omens being a means of communication from God with us, is exactly what I dont believe in. I do not believe in Alchemist’s too, who know everything beforehand, How can they, Are you kidding me ?? I hated the usage of Alchemist’s in this story the most. I could not believe when i read the part where the man offers the boy a glass of wine, on which the boy intorragates that Its haram to drink alchohol in Arab state, and our Alchemist replies,’It isnt what enters our mouth which is evil, it is what comes out of their mouths that is’. Bravo! Good choice of words, But its only partially true.Anyway … I am sorry Baikong, had to be this way, But i couldnt like it. Have no more to write about ths book now.
Anyone who fail to agree with me, Please feel free to express your opinions. Your comments and criticism is openly welcomed….
I thought it was beautifully written. You don’t have to believe in everything you read, I certainly agree with you on what you disliked but it’s a story right? A dream can mean different things to different people.
People are different so it’s normal that you don’t agree with all what you read yet reading inspires man’s (and woman’s) mind of course.
As for me, I liked the story from the point of view that a person might receive ’signs’ however he/she ignore them because of rushing and not pausing a little to think.
Assalam-alaikam,
This book was much-hyped in the UK and to be honest on reading it I also felt rather dissappointed. I didn’t enjoy it for the story or for the message. It felt a bit too obvious maybe.
I have read the Pursuit of Happyness and enjoyed it much more, I also felt it put the point across about pursuing your dreams much better.
Salam sis
I guess most of us will agree to disagree hmmm!!!
But your too funny babes, I couldnt like it huh???
Shouldnt it be I didnt like it lol like by choice…
Oh I also love the Pursuit of Happyiness such a touching story I think we can all learn from such lessons.
A very heart warming and will make you cry feel fuzzy inside kinda book:)
loved it loved it and could read it a million times over and would not get tired of it.
Friday, April 18, 2008 at '10:29 am'
Alchemist is one of my favorite books. The reason is not that I fully agree with the story or it impressed me but I just felt too motivated. I felt that dreams do come true and we have to struggle for it. I am not sure about omens and all other signs that were given but this book made me a firm believer that you have to make your destiny.
Just like I love teh movies, “Pursuit of happiness” & “Shawshank Redemption” These two movies motivated me alot. I just mentioned it.. I knwo it aint related